It occurred to me to write this short article on the benefits of taking or converting a colour image to black and white in post processing form. And also to work out why a man annoyed me so much this morning!
A man who interrupted my working in a public place today by proclaiming that no one should use photoshop made me really agitated and I think I am writing this to work out why:)
Ok, so he was a very rude man, but I think his attitude also highlights for me the hypocrisy of people who swear that images used by shooting film are not manipulated in the darkroom!
I have been in the industry 20 years and yes surprise surprise I used film… then four years ago I bought a digital camera…thought it was about time..and it was.
The above image, was shot in colour negative film, scanned in and then converted into black and white on post processing software. Although I must admit I am not a fan of heavily processed images I do like black and white images that have had some processing. I don’t see modifying an image a problem because the simple fact is that we used to manipulate images it was called having darkroom skills, and yes it is a skill but so is traipsing out into the countryside with a heavy camera across harsh terrain and getting great shots in wild places.
The camera I am afraid has always lied, the representation that we see through the viewfinder of the world is not the world, it’s a representation of it. This has always been the fact. The true skill a photographer has is to capture a moment and make it last forever using light angles solid composition and well frankly, luck!
I have a love of black and white imagery in Photography, the way the monochrome tones can transform a bland image into something otherworldly has always fascinated me.
I guess for black and white photography you need three things, tone, texture and form for the composition to work.
Once you have these things and a reasonable subject you are away!
The image below (I hope) has all three:
I guess I find the posturing in the photographic world hard to take sometimes, the truth is what we do is being devalued enough these days without us devaluing each other.
Yes I do concede that we are being devalued but then so is every major craft skill that can be mass produced !
I still love black and white though, whether it be film digital or animal.